|
WELDABILITY OF METALS AND
ALLOYS Steels
Steel is the general name given to a wide range of alloys of iron
and carbon with or without the purposeful addition of other
alloying metals. The carbon imparts higher strength to the iron
and the ability, over a certain percentage to permit hardening and
a wide range of structural properties by heat treatment.
Increasing carbon content of steel gives increased ease of
hardening with higher strength but lower ductility. Tougher steels
with superior properties can be achieved by replacing some of the
added carbon with other alloying elements such as chromium,
nickel, molybdenum etc. modifying the structure of the metal in
different forms.
Welding is of course a form of heat treatment on a joint and as a
general rule the more easily hardened and higher tensile the
steel, the more difficult they are to weld.
For our purposes they can be considered in the following general
groups:
1. Mild Steel (Low carbon
steel)
The term mild refers to its relative inability to be
hardened to any practical extent by normal heat treatments. It is
a low carbon steel with a general range of 0.05% up to 0.3% carbon
and forms the vast bulk of the steels employed for general
structural fabrication, sheet metal etc. Tensile strength is of
the order of 400‑450MPa and it is ductile and easily worked. It is
readily able to be welded by all common processes and offers no
special problems to the general arc welder other than those
normally pertaining to distortion control etc.
2. Medium Carbon Steels
Steels with a range of 0.35% ‑ 0.6% carbon are heat treatable to
higher strengths than mild steel but require special precautions
in welding for this reason. These steels, usually also having a
slightly higher manganese content (0.6‑1 %) are used for higher
strength bar stock in machine frames, shafts, sprockets and cast
steel tractor components, rail lines etc. Use low hydrogen
electrodes with a preheat up to 250°C in the heavier sections.
3. Low Alloy High Tensile
Steels
This group generally fall into the same welding characteristics as
the medium carbon steels, although many can achieve higher
strengths and ductility but with better weldability than the
equivalent plain carbon alternative. When carbon is partially
replaced by alternative alloying elements such as chromium,
nickel, molybdenum, vanadium etc., the toughness, impact
resistance and general mechanical properties are improved. Special
low alloy electrodes are available for special critical
applications using these steels where the weld properties must
fully match the parent metal but satisfactory general welding can
often be conducted with the standard low hydrogen electrodes.
4. High Carbon Steels
Steel containing 0.65 ‑1.5% carbon are referred to as high carbons
steels and again, various alloy modifications of the plain carbon
steel are available giving enhanced specific properties of one
type or another. Their high hardness makes them difficult to weld
and for some applications satisfactory results can not be
guaranteed. In other instances, special high alloy electrodes and
high preheats, followed often by heat treatment, achieve a
satisfactory result.
These classes of steels are used where a sharp edge must be
maintained or where high hardness is essential to their service
conditions. Often referred to as tool steels, their applications
vary from chisels, axes, files, etc., to hot or cold forging dies,
guillotines blades etc.
5. Austenitic Steels
The exception to the rule of obtaining higher hardness by
quenching of steels from elevated temperatures are two steels in
specialised fields of uses which come under the name of Austenitic
Steels. These steels are non‑magnetic.
Austenitic
Manganese Steel is supplied in a toughened quenched condition. It
is only partially stable and under heat or impact can harden to a
brittle wear resistance structure. It can be welded with an alloy
of similar composition or preferably for strength welds with an
Austenitic stainless steel class of alloy but ordinary mild steel
electrode should never be employed due to hard brittle fusion zone
alloys being formed.
|
Because of the detrimental effect of excess heat on the
toughness of the material, it should be welded cold, the area
being no more than hand hot before the next run is deposited. This
may be accomplished by skip welding, welding on several components
in turn or even welding in a water bath with only the area to be
welded exposed. It is extensively employed in quarry and dredging
equipment where its work hardening properties and tough structural
properties are used to advantage.
Austenitic Stainless Steel is also non‑magnetic and contains
sufficient chromium and nickel to ensure a tough corrosion
resistant alloy. Being non‑heat‑treatable it has good welding
characteristics with electrodes of similar composition and is used
extensively because of its many excellent properties in the
dairying equipment, beverage and food processing fields as well as
for architectural and domestic hardware. Its cost usually
prohibits its use in general fabrication applications where
cheaper steels of similar strengths are available unless of course
highly corrosive conditions are encountered such as in chemical
plant. When welding stainless to mild steel use a high alloyed
stainless steel to offset dilution of the weld metal.
Cast Irons
A
range of iron/carbon alloys containing 2.5 ‑ 3.5% carbon are
produced for casting purposes and the general manner in which the
high carbon content is present determines their major properties
and characteristics. Grey Cast Iron, in which a large proportion
of the carbon is present as graphite flakes is the most widely
used for a whole range of sand cast goods requiring a good
compressive strength but with little need for ductility. Machine
bases, automotive engine blocks, pipes, sprocket gears etc. It
derives its name from the characteristic grey colour of the
fractured iron. The presence of the carbon as graphite reduces the
strength of the iron in tension although machining is excellent
for this reason.
White Cast Iron, is cast in steel moulds and the faster cooling
and modified composition ensures the presence of the carbon mainly
as white iron carbide. The white iron shows good wear resistance
but is very brittle. In heavy sections the components are often
designated as chilled cast irons due to the wear resistant white
iron layer close to the surface with a modified grey iron of
tougher characteristics in the core of the component.
Malleable, Ductile and SG Irons and Meehanite are all special
irons in which additional elements are added to improve certain
properties, notably strength and toughness. The most common of the
higher strength types rely on obtaining the graphite in round
balls rather than flakes and strengthening of the matrix to a
level where its tensile strength is comparable with mild steel and
bend strength is quite good. These irons are being increasingly
employed in the agricultural component field in small gears etc.
Welding of cast irons is made difficult by the fact that no matter
what form it is in, the carbon present is re-dissolved in the
fusion zone and due to the quenching effect, a brittle white iron
is formed. Similarly its absorption by normal steel weld metals
produces a very hard brittle high carbon weld metal.
Weldability
is best in SG or malleable group irons while white irons are
rarely considered as weldable for most practical applications.
Most people use a nickel / iron or monel type of electrode as all
these alloys can absorb carbon without hardening thus ensuring a
relatively soft ductile weld. Bronze electrodes can also be
employed. Braze welding with the
oxyacetylene process is a good method for grey cast iron but is
unsuitable for SG irons where the high heat destroys the structure
of the iron, reducing its strength to a grey iron level.
Cast irons are generally arc welded with only a small amount of
heat, care being taken to use short peened runs and to restrict
any tendency to heat buildup above hand hot, thus restricting the
width of the hardened zone and welding stresses on the low
ductility material.
Grind or chip cracked section to open groove (not narrow vee)
leaving a small section for mating parts
|